검색 상세

National Bioethics Committee's report on bioethical problems in Hwang Woo-suk research

  • 설명문(일반) "National Bioethics Committee, Republic of Korea, November 2006"
  • 지원기관 Supported by the Minister of Health, Welfare and Family Affairs, Korea.
  • 발행기관 Bioethics Policy Research Center
  • 제작일 2008-12-28
  • 발행년도 2008
  • 원문페이지 87 p.
  • URI http://www.dcollection.net/handler/ewha/000000081543
  • ISBN 9788993244205
  • 본문언어 영어
  • 제출원본 http://lib.ewha.ac.kr/search/detail/CAT000001345054

목차

I. Introduction 1
II. Judgment standards 2
1. Domestic Regulations 3
2. International Codes 3
III. Number and source of human oocytes provided for Dr. Hwang's research 4
1. Number of Oocyte Donors and Collected Oocytes 4
2. Number of Oocytes Provided by Each Institution 4
3. Type of Oocyte Donors 6
4. Ovaries Donated for Research Purpose 8
5. Conclusion 9
IV. Ethical issues in oocyte donation for Dr. Hwang's team 10
1. Premises of Discussion 10
2. Ethical Review of Paid Donation 15
3. Ethical Review of Benefit-in-kind Donation 18
4. Ethical Review of Voluntary Donation 21
5. Ethical Review of Informed Consent 23
6. Ethical Review of Health Protection of Oocyte Donors 28
7. Ethical Review of Ovary Excision and Donation 30
8. Conclusion 34
V. Ethical issues concerning researcher donation in Dr. Hwang's team 36
1. Premises of Discussion 36
2. Donation by Female Researchers 39
3. Whether Researcher Donation Was Voluntary 43
4. Whether Researchers Received Any Benefits 47
5. When Dr. Hwang Recognized Donation by Female Researchers 48
6. Conclusion 49
VI. Appropriateness of IRB oversight of Dr. Hwang's research 51
1. Premises of Discussion 51
2. Oversight by the IRB of Hanyang University Hospital in Seoul 59
3. Oversight of the IRB of Hanyang University Hospital in Guri 68
4. Oversight by the IRB of College of Veterinary Medicine, SNU 70
5. IRB Oversight of Other Institutions 75
6. Conclusion 78
VII. Policy proposal 79
1. Bioethics for Research Involving Human Subjects 80
2. Establishing a National Direction of Research on Somatic Cell Cloning Embryo 80
3. Enhancing Management and Oversight of Gametes 81
4. Ensuring Reliable Operation of IRBs 81
5. Establishing Bioethics and Safety Infrastructure 82
6. Promoting Ethical Awareness 83
VIII. Conclusion 84

more